Sinister Eye Red Eye Metal Butt Plug

Price range: $15.99 through $25.99

A fantasy-themed metal butt plug with a mesmerizing glass eye centerpiece — available in three sizes to match your experience level. Plug into something extraordinary with temperature play potential and a design that’s equal parts wicked and stunning.

Weight0.42 oz
Brand:
Color:
Audience
Size:
Material
Length:
Add $69.00 for FREE standard shipping
Description

Metal Butt Plug Glass Eye — Sinister Eye by XR Brands

A metal butt plug glass eye that turns temperature play into fantasy.

Some plugs fill a need. The Sinister Eye fills a fantasy. This nickel-free metal butt plug carries a genuine red glass eye at its base — a visual detail you keep entirely to yourself. Available in small, medium, and large, it scales with your comfort and curiosity.

Metal Butt Plug Glass Eye Features & Specifications

Six reasons the Sinister Eye stands out in the anal plug gems category.

Material & Care

  • Nickel-free metal shaft, body-safe
  • Genuine red glass eye inset
  • Rinse with warm water and mild soap

Body-Safe Metal Build

  • Non-porous, easy to clean thoroughly
  • Compatible with water-based lubricants
  • Silicone-based lube compatible too

Temperature Play Ready

  • Warm or cool under running water
  • Metal holds temperature beautifully
  • Check against wrist before use

Safe Design: Flanged Base

  • Tapered tip for gradual insertion
  • Narrow neck seats naturally
  • Flanged base prevents over-insertion

Three Sizes Available

  • Small, medium, and large options
  • Under-4-inch insertable length
  • 1.5-inch widest insertable diameter (large)

Fantasy Style & Finish

  • Red glass eye visual centerpiece
  • Polished black and red metal finish
  • Discreet gem-style aesthetic

Metal Butt Plug Glass Eye User Guide & Play Styles

Solo exploration with a nickel-free metal butt plug glass eye.

Solo sessions are where most people get comfortable with plug wear, and the Sinister Eye is well-suited for exactly that. The tapered tip makes initial insertion manageable, and the narrow neck encourages a natural resting position once seated. Choose small if you’re building toward fuller wear, or step into the large for a more present, weighted sensation. The smooth metal material warms quickly to body temperature during wear, so what starts as a cool contact becomes barely-there comfort. For a deeper look at anal play basics, the guide to anal sex at Discreet Toys covers everything from lube to pacing. Apply a generous amount of water-based lubricant before insertion, and clean the metal surface with warm water and mild soap after every session.

Temperature play and sensory variety with this glass eye butt plug.

The XR Brands Sinister Eye was built with temperature play in mind. Run the nickel-free metal plug under warm water for a soothing heat sensation, or cool it briefly for a sharp, invigorating contrast — always check the temperature against your inner wrist before use. The red glass eye at the base stays cool longer than the metal shaft, adding an unexpected textural and visual element to the experience. Explore more options in the anal plug gems collection if you want to compare styles and sizes. The under-4-inch insertable length keeps this plug approachable across all three size variants, while the flanged base means removal is always straightforward and safe.

Plain-Box Shipping
Ships in 1-2 Business Days
Veteran Owned
Body-Safe Materials

Discreet Toys is veteran-owned and operated. Every order ships in a plain brown box with a discreet billing descriptor — your privacy is the priority from checkout to doorstep. Questions about your order? Our returns & refund policy covers the details. Free shipping on orders $69 or more.

It’s only freaky the first time.

Shipping & Delivery
📦 Discreet Shipping

Free Shipping
on Orders $69+

Or any product with a HOT label. Free Standard Shipping applies automatically at checkout, no code needed. Every order ships within 1 business day in a plain brown box.

Pick Your Speed at Checkout

Priority Mail (USPS)
$17.95
$9.95 on orders $69+.
Arrives in 2–3 business days.
Priority Mail Express (USPS)
$49.95
$41.95 on orders $69+.
Arrives in 1–3 business days.

Delivery days count from the day your order ships. They're estimates, not guarantees. Orders of $200 or more may be held up to 3 business days for verification before they ship. Packages over 5 lb add a weight-based charge, shown at checkout before you pay. Read the full shipping policy

📦

Plain Brown Box

No logos and no product names on the box. The label never says Discreet.toys or what's inside.

🤫

Discreet Billing

Your card statement shows DT WELLNESS STORE, never Discreet Toys or what you bought.

⚡

Tracking by Email

We email your tracking number once your order ships.

How Your Order Arrives

🛒
1
Order Placed

Pick your shipping speed at checkout

›
📦
2
Packed Discreetly

Plain brown box, discreet label

›
🚚
3
Ships in 1 Business Day

Tracking emailed to you

›
🏠
4
At Your Door

2–5 business days on Standard, sooner with Priority or Express