Boy Butter brand logo

Boy Butter — Lubricants 2026

Updated June 2026

Founded in 2003, Boy Butter has built its catalog around water based, oil based, and desensitizing. We stock the Boy Butter pieces we’d actually recommend to a friend, shipped in a plain brown box with a discreet billing descriptor.

Free shipping on orders $69+. The label on the box and the descriptor on your card statement are both deliberately vague — your secret is safe with us. Discreet Toys is veteran-owned, customer-supported, and judgment-free.

Showing all 10 resultsSorted by price: high to low

Show sidebar

Filter By Price
    Filter
    Sort by
    By Color

      Boy Butter Gold 16 oz oil based personal lubricant jar by Boy Butter
      $34.50

      Boy Butter Gold 16 Oz

      You'll Never Know It Isn't Boy Butter 16 oz 473ml Boy Butter H2O cream formula jar by Boy Butter
      $33.00

      You’ll Never Know It Isn’t Boy Butter – 16 Oz./ 473ml – Boy Butter H2O Cream Formula

      Boy Butter Original Lubricant coconut oil-based personal lubricant by Boy Butter
      Price range: $13.75 through $33.00

      Boy Butter Original Lubricant

      You'll Never Know It Isn't Boy Butter 9 Oz Squeeze Bottle by Boy Butter water-based lubricant
      $27.25

      You’ll Never Know It Isn’t Boy Butter 9 Oz Squeeze Bottle

      Youll Never Know It Isnt Boy Butter 8 Fl Oz Water Based Lubricant Tub by Boy Butter
      $24.00

      You’ll Never Know It Isn’t Boy Butter – 8 Fl. Oz./ 237ml Tub

      Boy Butter Clear H2O water based personal lubricant pump bottle by Boy Butter
      Price range: $11.25 through $20.00

      Boy Butter Clear H2O

      $14.50

      Boy Butter H2O 4oz Tub

      You'll Never Know It Isn't Boy Butter 2 oz pump water based lubricant by Boy Butter
      $12.00

      You’ll Never Know It Isn’t Boy Butter – 2 Oz. Pump

      Boy Butter Original 2 Oz Pump oil based personal lubricant by Boy Butter
      $12.00

      Boy Butter Original 2 Oz Pump

      About Boy Butter

      Boy Butter was founded in 2003, based in USA. Founded by Eyal Feldman. The company is known for oil-based and water-based personal lubricants in butter-tub packaging, and we stock the Boy Butter pieces that fit the kind of customer we serve at Discreet Toys: first-timers and experienced buyers alike.

      If you're new to the category and not sure whether Boy Butter is the right fit, start with the product descriptions on each page or email us before you order. We'll help you sort through it.

      Choosing Lubricant — Water-Based, Silicone & Boy Butter Compatibility

      Water-based lubricants are the safe default — condom-compatible and toy-safe across all material types. Silicone-based lubricants last longer and are great for shower play, but they should not be used with silicone toys — they can degrade the surface over time. Boy Butter formulas vary in feel, viscosity, and ingredient list, so check the label if you have sensitivities. Glycerin- and paraben-free formulas are the gentler call for anyone prone to irritation. Healthline's personal-lubricant overview walks through the categories. A patch test on the inside of your wrist is a good first step with any new product.

      Discreet Shipping for Boy Butter — What Arrives at Your Door

      Every Boy Butter order ships in a plain brown box with a discreet billing descriptor — no logos, no product names anywhere on the outside, nothing on your card statement that hints at what you bought. Most orders arrive in three days via USPS Priority. Free shipping on orders $69+. Questions before you order? Email contactus@discreet.toys — we answer questions from first-time buyers every day, judgment-free. Discreet Toys is veteran-owned and operated.

      It's only freaky the first time.