Best Anal Plugs for Beginners — A Comfortable First Step Into Backdoor Pleasure

Best anal plugs for beginners share a few key traits: they are small, tapered for easy insertion, made from body-safe materials, and feature a flared base that prevents the plug from travelling too far. If you have been curious about anal play but felt nervous about where to start, a beginner plug is the safest and most comfortable entry point.

Our backdoor pleasure hub covers every category from plugs and beads to prostate toys and anal vibrators. According to Healthline, using plenty of lubricant, starting small, and going slowly are the most important safety practices for enjoyable anal play.

What to Look for in the Best Anal Plugs for Beginners

Size matters most. Look for plugs labelled “small” or “petite” with an insertable width under 1.25 inches. A narrow, tapered tip allows gradual insertion so your body can adjust at its own pace without discomfort.

Material is critical. Medical-grade silicone is the gold standard — it is non-porous, hypoallergenic, and easy to sterilise. Stainless steel and aluminium plugs are also body-safe and offer a smooth, weighted feel that many beginners enjoy. Our materials guide explains the differences in detail.

Flared base is non-negotiable. Every plug designed for anal use must have a wide, flared base or a T-bar handle. This prevents the plug from being pulled inward by the body’s natural muscles. Never use a toy without a proper base for anal play.

Best Anal Plugs for Beginners — Our Top Picks for 2026

The Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Beginner Plug is our top recommendation for first-timers. It is made from premium platinum-cured silicone, has a gentle taper, and the small size eases insertion without feeling overwhelming. The wide suction-cup base doubles as a safety feature and allows hands-free use.

The Luxe Beginner Plug from Blush Novelties comes in pink and black. Its ultra-smooth silicone surface and slim profile make it one of the most comfortable best anal plugs for beginners in our store. The rounded base sits flush and stays comfortable during extended wear.

For something with visual appeal, the Rear Assets Petite in Rose Gold features a polished metal body with a colourful jeweled base. Metal plugs warm quickly to body temperature and deliver a pleasant weighted sensation. They are also the easiest material to clean.

The Booty Sparks Light-Up Plug adds a playful twist — an LED light in the base that glows through the translucent silicone body. It is a fun conversation starter that helps take the pressure off a new experience.

Ready for vibration? The Luxe Wearable Vibra Slim Plug combines a slim beginner profile with a built-in vibrating bullet. The vibration relaxes muscles and increases arousal, making insertion even easier. Browse the full anal plugs and vibrating anal plugs categories for every option.

Silicone vs Metal — Which Are the Best Anal Plugs for Beginners?

Silicone plugs are flexible, lightweight, and feel softer against the body. They are ideal if you want a gentle, forgiving first experience. Use only water-based lubricant with silicone toys — silicone-based lube can damage the surface over time.

Metal plugs are firm, smooth, and offer a satisfying sense of fullness even at small sizes. They can be used with any type of lubricant and are compatible with temperature play — warm them in hot water or cool them in the fridge for extra sensation.

If you enjoy the idea of anal beads or prostate toys, a small plug is the perfect stepping stone into backdoor play.

How to Use the Best Anal Plugs for Beginners Safely

Apply a generous amount of lubricant to both the plug and yourself. Relax, breathe deeply, and insert the tip slowly — let your body set the pace. Once the plug is seated, give yourself time to adjust before adding any other stimulation. Read our full guide to anal play and benefits of using butt plugs for detailed tips.

Cleaning and Care for Your Best Anal Plugs for Beginners

Clean your plug with warm water and toy cleaner before and after every use. Silicone and metal plugs can also be sterilised by boiling for 3–5 minutes. Store in a lint-free pouch to keep the surface smooth. Our features guide covers waterproof ratings and other details to look for.

Why Beginners Choose Discreet Toys for the Best Anal Plugs for Beginners

Discreet Toys is veteran-owned and ships every order in plain, unmarked packaging with 3-day delivery. We understand that buying your first plug can feel intimidating — that is why privacy is built into everything we do. Explore our full backdoor pleasure hub to discover anal vibrators, anal kits, and everything else you need for a safe, enjoyable experience.

← Explore all Backdoor Pleasure categories